Supreme Court Shocker: Media’s First Amendment Battle Revealed in Landmark Case!

The justices of the may have concerns regarding the media.

On Monday, the Supreme Court listened to arguments in Murthy v. Missouri, a case addressing whether the government violated companies' First Amendment rights by pressuring them to make specific content decisions.

Justice John Roberts and Biden
Justice John Roberts and (Image source: Twitter)

During the proceedings, the justices questioned what constitutes coercion and the extent to which the government can influence social media conduct.

The case arose from complaints filed by Missouri and Louisiana alleging censorship by government entities such as the White House and CDC, regarding -19 vaccine misinformation and fraud theories.

This case is one of several the court will consider regarding social media and the First Amendment this year. Justices expressed varying views during arguments. Justice Alito characterized platforms like Facebook as “subordinates” to the government and criticized the government's persistent pressure on social media companies. Conversely, Justice Kavanaugh disagreed, citing his experience of government officials engaging with the media regularly. Justice Kagan shared similar experiences, noting frequent interactions between the government and the press.

Chief Justice Roberts humorously remarked that he had never coerced anyone but agreed that government agencies hold diverse perspectives on social media moderation. Justice Jackson raised a hypothetical scenario about dangerous internet challenges, questioning whether the government could intervene during public health emergencies. Louisiana Solicitor General Aguiñaga argued against government intervention, emphasizing free speech concerns.

While media outlets predict the court may favor the Biden administration's stance that its actions were not coercion, a final decision is not expected until June or July. An injunction from the Fifth Circuit of Appeals previously restricted government officials from contacting social media companies, but it is unlikely the Supreme Court will uphold it. Requests for comment from the involved parties were not immediately answered.

Leave a Reply